AI news, problem solutions & tool picks
DigestX

Problem Solutions

Letting AI do all the writing makes it worse, a study finds

· 2 min read

Photo via Pexels

Handing all the writing to AI makes the writing worse. That is the finding of a study by Kartik Hosanagar and Daehwan Ahn, published in PNAS Nexus in 2026, in which 285 students in an elective course on emerging technologies wrote a 1,000-word story and then used ChatGPT 3.5 under three different designs. The stories came out 36.2% faster with AI. But speed was not the whole story: how the students used the AI decided whether the result was better or worse than writing alone.

Three ways to use AI, three different results

In the first design, Human Confirmation, the AI did the ideas, the outline, the draft and the editing, and the humans merely approved each step. In the second, Human Creativity, the humans generated the ideas, chose the concept and wrote the outline, and the AI drafted and edited. In the third, Copilot, the AI supported the writer at any stage they chose. Human readers rated the stories afterwards, without knowing which design produced them.

The approval trap

The Human Confirmation stories came out worse than stories written with no AI at all. The Human Creativity and Copilot stories came out better than human-only work. Weaker writers showed the larger gains. The Human Creativity and Copilot groups also reported higher satisfaction with the process, while the Human Confirmation participants expressed less pride in the result. The readers' complaints about AI-written stories were consistent: they lacked emotional depth, originality and nuance, and the tone and plot did not hold together.

What this means for your writing

The lesson is about where the thinking happens. When the human keeps the ideas, the concept and the outline, and the AI does the drafting and editing, the result beats writing alone. When the human hands over the thinking and only approves, the result is worse than not using AI at all. If you write with AI, keep the decisions that make a piece yours: the idea, the angle, the structure. Let the AI do the sentences, not the thinking.